Best Columbus, OH Independent Insurance Agents

Find an insurance agent that fits your needs and connect with them today.

Showing 111 agencies in Columbus, OH

Recommended elite-level agency with higher expertise to match insurance coverage. Recommended Local Agency Open Now 0.6 miles
Detwiler-Brofford Insurance, Inc.
5 (5)
  • Personal
  • Life
130 E Chestnut St Ste 200, Columbus, OH, 43215-2598
Open Now 0.6 miles
Detwiler-Brofford Insurance, Inc.'s logo
Recommended elite-level agency with higher expertise to match insurance coverage. Recommended Local Agency Open Now 1.1 miles
W.E. Davis Insurance Agency Inc
5 (3)
  • Personal
  • Business
  • Life
29 Frederick St, Columbus, OH, 43206-2516
Open Now 1.1 miles
W.E. Davis Insurance Agency Inc's logo
Recommended elite-level agency with higher expertise to match insurance coverage. Recommended Local Agency Open Now 4.1 miles
Thomas-Fenner-Woods Agy, Inc.
5 (8)
  • Personal
  • Business
  • Life
1500 Lake Shore Dr Ste 400, Columbus, OH, 43204-3891
Open Now 4.1 miles
Thomas-Fenner-Woods Agy, Inc.'s logo
Recommended elite-level agency with higher expertise to match insurance coverage. Recommended Local Agency Open Now 5.7 miles
Horizon Insurance Services, Inc.
5 (6)
  • Personal
  • Business
  • Life
3806 N High St, Columbus, OH, 43214-3527
Open Now 5.7 miles
Horizon Insurance Services, Inc.'s logo
Open Now 3.6 miles
Briggs & Williams Insurance LLC
5 (8)
  • Business
1335 Dublin Rd Ste 110D, Columbus, OH, 43215-7113
Open Now 3.6 miles
Briggs & Williams Insurance LLC's logo
Open Now 4.7 miles
Pfeifer-Ornstein Insurance Agency LLC
5 (4)
  • Personal
  • Business
  • Life
3291 E Main St, Columbus, OH, 43213-2740
Open Now 4.7 miles
Pfeifer-Ornstein Insurance Agency LLC's logo
Open Now 9.8 miles
K&M Insurance Agency, Inc. DBA John Dawson Associates
  • Personal
  • Business
  • Life
6025 Cleveland Ave, Columbus, OH, 43231-2256
Open Now 9.8 miles
K&M Insurance Agency, Inc. DBA John Dawson Associates's logo
Assurex Agency Inc
175 S 3rd St Ste 800, Columbus, OH, 43215-5194
Assurex Agency Inc's logo
OIA Service Corporation
175 S 3rd St Ste 940, Columbus, OH, 43215-5197
OIA Service Corporation's logo
Go Fund Your Life
175 S 3rd St, Columbus, OH, 43215-5134
Go Fund Your Life's logo
delete
41 S High St Ste 240, Columbus, OH, 43215-6137
delete's logo
Ohio Chamber of Commerce / Ohio Chamber Insurance Agency, Inc.
34 S 3rd St Ste 100, Columbus, OH, 43215-3082
Ohio Chamber of Commerce / Ohio Chamber Insurance Agency, Inc.'s logo
Sylvia A Garrett & Associates Agency, LLC
20 S 3rd St, Columbus, OH, 43215-4206
Sylvia A Garrett & Associates Agency, LLC's logo
Branch Insurance
20 E Broad St # 1200, Columbus, OH, 43215-3403
Branch Insurance's logo
Call Insurance Agency, Inc.
21 W Broad St Ste 200, Columbus, OH, 43215-4166
Call Insurance Agency, Inc.'s logo
Sherry A. Dancy DBA The Dancy Group LLC
150 E Mound St Ste 202, Columbus, OH, 43215-5429
Sherry A. Dancy DBA The Dancy Group LLC's logo
MeyMax Title Agency
380 S. High St, Suite 330, Columbus, OH, 43215
MeyMax Title Agency's logo
QuickInsured.com LLC
500 S Front St Ste 840, Columbus, OH, 43215-7634
QuickInsured.com LLC's logo
Strategic Ins. Software Inc.
395 E Broad St Ste 300, Columbus, OH, 43215-3844
Strategic Ins. Software Inc.'s logo
DeFusco & Associates Insurance, Inc.
538 E Town St, Columbus, OH, 43215-4835
DeFusco & Associates Insurance, Inc.'s logo
Nationwide
1 Nationwide Plz, Columbus, OH, 43215-2226
Nationwide's logo
Agency Sold--Bennett Insurance Agency LLC
700 S High St, Columbus, OH, 43206-1044
Agency Sold--Bennett Insurance Agency LLC's logo
Catanzaro Insurance LLC
729 S 3rd St, Columbus, OH, 43206-1027
Catanzaro Insurance LLC's logo
Assured Partners NL
285 Cozzins St, Columbus, OH, 43215-2334
Assured Partners NL's logo
Foxen
333 W Nationwide Blvd, Columbus, OH, 43215-2311
Foxen's logo
J. B. Oswald Co. dba Oswald Companies
353 W Nationwide Blvd, Columbus, OH, 43215-2311
J. B. Oswald Co. dba Oswald Companies's logo
DeHan Enterprises Insurance & Financial Services Agency LLC
762 E Main St, Columbus, OH, 43205-1715
DeHan Enterprises Insurance & Financial Services Agency LLC's logo
Tim Reis Insurance Agency Inc.
931 S High St, Columbus, OH, 43206-2523
Tim Reis Insurance Agency Inc.'s logo
Wells Fargo Insurance Services of Ohio LLC
580 N 4th St Ste 400, Columbus, OH, 43215-2153
Wells Fargo Insurance Services of Ohio LLC's logo
Phillips Insurance Agency, Inc.
938 Dennison Ave, Columbus, OH, 43201-3442
Phillips Insurance Agency, Inc.'s logo
American Church Group of Ohio LLC
777 Goodale Blvd Ste 400, Columbus, OH, 43212-3862
American Church Group of Ohio LLC's logo
AA Affordable Insurance Agency of Ohio
1180 W Broad St, Columbus, OH, 43222-1319
AA Affordable Insurance Agency of Ohio's logo
Pitts Insurance Agency
1313 E Broad St Ste 202, Columbus, OH, 43205-3510
Pitts Insurance Agency's logo
Willis Towers Watson
775 Yard St Ste 200, Columbus, OH, 43212-3891
Willis Towers Watson's logo
Nationwide
1000 Yard St, Columbus, OH, 43212-3905
Nationwide's logo
Sokol Insurance Agency, LLC dba Sokol Eisenberg Insurance
1620 E Broad St Ste 103, Columbus, OH, 43203-2012
Sokol Insurance Agency, LLC dba Sokol Eisenberg Insurance's logo
Grandview Insurance Agency LLC
1500 W 3rd Ave Ste 300F, Columbus, OH, 43212-2843
Grandview Insurance Agency LLC's logo
Dressel & Evans Agency, Inc.
1527 Northwest Blvd, Columbus, OH, 43212-2536
Dressel & Evans Agency, Inc.'s logo
Dovetail Consulting Agency
805 S Cassingham Rd, Columbus, OH, 43209-5409
Dovetail Consulting Agency's logo
Maloof Ins Agcy
2362 N High St, Columbus, OH, 43202-2922
Maloof Ins Agcy's logo
Brubaker Insurance
2700 E Main St Ste 205, Columbus, OH, 43209-2536
Brubaker Insurance's logo
Beim-Grundstein & Associates Insurance Services
2776 E Main St, Columbus, OH, 43209-2518
Beim-Grundstein & Associates Insurance Services's logo
Ledbetter Insurance Group
1767 Harrisburg Pike, Columbus, OH, 43223-3664
Ledbetter Insurance Group's logo
B. Rupp Agency, Inc.
1349 W Lane Ave Ste 1000B, Columbus, OH, 43221-3636
B. Rupp Agency, Inc.'s logo
Gardiner Allen DeRoberts Insurance LLC
1349 W Lane Ave, Columbus, OH, 43221-3636
Gardiner Allen DeRoberts Insurance LLC's logo
Heights Insurance Agency
1286 W Lane Ave, Columbus, OH, 43221-3547
Heights Insurance Agency's logo
Johnson Insurance Agency
685 N Hague Ave, Columbus, OH, 43204-1422
Johnson Insurance Agency's logo
OSBA Insurance Agency / DBA Ohio Bar Insurance Agency
1650 Lake Shore Dr, Columbus, OH, 43204-4894
OSBA Insurance Agency / DBA Ohio Bar Insurance Agency's logo
Ford Adam Insurance Agency Inc.
3043 W Broad St Ste B, Columbus, OH, 43204-2674
Ford Adam Insurance Agency Inc.'s logo
Soller Insurance Agency
891 S James Rd, Columbus, OH, 43227-1069
Soller Insurance Agency's logo
Agency Sold-MacKinnon Insurance
921 Chatham Ln Ste 300, Columbus, OH, 43221-2418
Agency Sold-MacKinnon Insurance's logo
Agency Sold-PIQ LLC
2939 Kenny Rd Ste 201, Columbus, OH, 43221-2478
Agency Sold-PIQ LLC's logo
Agency Sole-Ballou Insurance Agency Inc.
2810 Cleveland Ave, Columbus, OH, 43224-4410
Agency Sole-Ballou Insurance Agency Inc.'s logo
Dan Coonfare Agency LLC
1080 Fishinger Rd, Columbus, OH, 43221-2302
Dan Coonfare Agency LLC's logo
Guardian Insurance Solutions
1071 Fishinger Rd Ste 112, Columbus, OH, 43221-2376
Guardian Insurance Solutions's logo
Apollo Insurance Agency
3465 Indianola Ave, Columbus, OH, 43214-3809
Apollo Insurance Agency's logo
Matson Insurance Agency
1275 Demorest Rd, Columbus, OH, 43204-1041
Matson Insurance Agency's logo
J. R. Scott Insurance Agency, Inc.
3620 N High St Ste 203, Columbus, OH, 43214-3643
J. R. Scott Insurance Agency, Inc.'s logo
Agency Sold-Wolfe Insurance Group LLC
1580 Fishinger Rd Ste 200E, Columbus, OH, 43221-2107
Agency Sold-Wolfe Insurance Group LLC's logo
Ray Insurance Agency
1580 Fishinger Rd, Columbus, OH, 43221-2107
Ray Insurance Agency's logo
Isner Insurance Associates Inc
3695 N High St, Columbus, OH, 43214-3520
Isner Insurance Associates Inc's logo
Augustine Insurance Agency, LLC
3851 N High St, Columbus, OH, 43214-3751
Augustine Insurance Agency, LLC's logo
State Auto Insurance Company
PO Box 182822, Columbus, OH, 43218-2822
State Auto Insurance Company's logo
Integrated Financial Systems Agency, Inc.
4207 E Broad St Ste F, Columbus, OH, 43213-1200
Integrated Financial Systems Agency, Inc.'s logo
Baum & Associates Insurance Agency
170 S Yearling Rd, Columbus, OH, 43213-1868
Baum & Associates Insurance Agency's logo
Putnam White Lewis Insurance Agency, Inc.
4161 N High St Ste A, Columbus, OH, 43214-3065
Putnam White Lewis Insurance Agency, Inc.'s logo
Grubers Columbus Agency
3040 Riverside Dr, Columbus, OH, 43221-2551
Grubers Columbus Agency's logo
Agency Sold-Devenne Insurance LLC
4255 N High, Columbus, OH, 43214
Agency Sold-Devenne Insurance LLC's logo
Connor Insurance Agency Inc.
4255 N High St, Columbus, OH, 43214-3049
Connor Insurance Agency Inc.'s logo
Botkin Insurance Services
4218 Indianola Ave, Columbus, OH, 43214-2826
Botkin Insurance Services's logo
Strategic Insurance Software/Partner XE
4181 Arlingate Plz, Columbus, OH, 43228-4115
Strategic Insurance Software/Partner XE's logo
Strategic Insurance Software
4181 ArlinGate Plaza, Columbus, OH, 43228
Strategic Insurance Software's logo
Murray & Sons Insurance Agency Inc.
301 S Hamilton Rd, Columbus, OH, 43213-2033
Murray & Sons Insurance Agency Inc.'s logo
Harp Insurance LLC
207 W Schreyer Pl, Columbus, OH, 43214-2522
Harp Insurance LLC's logo
Danduran & Associates Insurance Agency, Inc.
1827 Obrien Rd, Columbus, OH, 43228-3866
Danduran & Associates Insurance Agency, Inc.'s logo
Dan Evans Insurance Agency LLC
1150 Morse Rd Ste 102, Columbus, OH, 43229-6327
Dan Evans Insurance Agency LLC's logo
Solid Insurance
986 Morse Rd, Columbus, OH, 43229-6212
Solid Insurance's logo
The Golloh Group, LLC
700 Morse Rd Ste 208, Columbus, OH, 43214-1879
The Golloh Group, LLC's logo
Sumit & Associates
3535 Polley Rd, Columbus, OH, 43221-4760
Sumit & Associates's logo
Creekside Insurance Agency
83 Granville St, Columbus, OH, 43230
Creekside Insurance Agency's logo
Huntington Insurance
7 Easton Oval, Columbus, OH, 43219-6010
Huntington Insurance's logo
OH-INS, LLC DBA Overmyer Hall Associates
2000 Henderson Rd, Columbus, OH, 43220-2453
OH-INS, LLC DBA Overmyer Hall Associates's logo
Town & Village Insurance Service
2000 Henderson Rd Ste 340, Columbus, OH, 43220-2466
Town & Village Insurance Service's logo
Shield Insurance Agency LLC
4449 Easton Way Fl 2, Columbus, OH, 43219-7005
Shield Insurance Agency LLC's logo
Insurance Solutions Agency, Inc.
4200 Regent St Ste 200, Columbus, OH, 43219-6229
Insurance Solutions Agency, Inc.'s logo
Mark E. Watson & Associates
5020 Reed Rd Ste E, Columbus, OH, 43220-2581
Mark E. Watson & Associates's logo
Bepler Insurance LLC
3246 Noe Bixby Rd, Columbus, OH, 43232-6361
Bepler Insurance LLC's logo
Wiles Insurance Agency, LTD
348 Granville St Ste E, Columbus, OH, 43230-2926
Wiles Insurance Agency, LTD's logo
Lauterbach & Eilber, Inc.
1721 Bethel Rd, Columbus, OH, 43220-1836
Lauterbach & Eilber, Inc.'s logo
Reliable Insurance Brokers
4182 Worth Ave, Space 1-115, Columbus, OH, 43219
Reliable Insurance Brokers's logo
George D Santino Insurance Agency LLC
PO Box 30947, Columbus, OH, 43230-0947
George D Santino Insurance Agency LLC's logo
Frank & London Insurance Agency Inc.
6110 McNaughten Ctr # 12, Columbus, OH, 43232-1641
Frank & London Insurance Agency Inc.'s logo
Agency Sold - Dorsey Insurance Services Inc.
PO Box 32466, Columbus, OH, 43232-0466
Agency Sold - Dorsey Insurance Services Inc.'s logo
A2Z Insurance Agency LLC
5915 Karl Rd # 1, Columbus, OH, 43229-2664
A2Z Insurance Agency LLC's logo
Compare Quote LLC
5959 Scarborough Blvd Ste 4500, Columbus, OH, 43232-4750
Compare Quote LLC's logo
Compare Quote LLC
5959 Scarborough Blvd MS 4500, Columbus, OH, 43232-4750
Compare Quote LLC's logo
Phelps Financial Services Inc.
3985 Leather Stocking Trl, Columbus, OH, 43230-1528
Phelps Financial Services Inc.'s logo
Hamilton Insurance Group Inc
750 Cross Pointe Rd Ste G, Columbus, OH, 43230-6692
Hamilton Insurance Group Inc's logo
Ferrell Insurance Agency
5898 Cleveland Ave, Columbus, OH, 43231
Ferrell Insurance Agency's logo
Insurance Intermediaries, Inc.
6460 Busch Blvd Ste 100, Columbus, OH, 432291737
Insurance Intermediaries, Inc.'s logo
Columbus Cornerstone Construction
6589 Huntley Rd., Columbus, OH, 43229
Columbus Cornerstone Construction's logo
Pearl Interactive Network, Inc. (PIN)
1105 Schrock Rd Ste 107, Columbus, OH, 43229-1174
Pearl Interactive Network, Inc. (PIN)'s logo
MarketSource Agency Network, LLC
2500 Corporate Exchange Dr Ste 135, Columbus, OH, 43231-8622
MarketSource Agency Network, LLC's logo
Selective Insurance Group Inc
445 Hutchinson Ave Ste 740, Columbus, OH, 43235-5677
Selective Insurance Group Inc's logo
Safelite Auto Glass
7400 Safelite Way, Columbus, OH, 43235-5086
Safelite Auto Glass's logo
Agency Sold-All Ohio Insurance Agency, Inc.
180 Northwoods Blvd, Columbus, OH, 43235-4400
Agency Sold-All Ohio Insurance Agency, Inc.'s logo
Dawson Companies
8101 N High St Ste 30, Columbus, OH, 43235-1408
Dawson Companies's logo
Roby Foster Miller Earick
30 Northwoods Blvd Ste 300, Columbus, OH, 43235-4708
Roby Foster Miller Earick's logo
DELETE CLOSING OFFICE-DBG & Associates, Inc.
119 Dillmont Dr Ste 105, Columbus, OH, 43235-5695
DELETE CLOSING OFFICE-DBG & Associates, Inc.'s logo
Delete-Duplicate Westfield Services, Inc
2000 Polaris Pkwy, Columbus, OH, 43240-2108
Delete-Duplicate Westfield Services, Inc's logo
Rivers Insurance Group
9039 Antares Ave Ste G2B, Columbus, OH, 43240-4067
Rivers Insurance Group's logo

Not sure which agency to choose?

Let us recommend an agency based on your insurance needs.

Find a recommended agent